How to Tackle a Review

From TED Translators Wiki
Revision as of 08:39, 13 August 2012 by Snai (talk | contribs)
Jump to: navigation, search

What is the job of a reviewer?

A reviewer is not simply a person who ensures that the translation is passable and gramatically correct. The reviewer should catch any translation errors (punctuation, interpretation, mistranslations...) and give feedback to make the style better.

The job of a reviewer is to make sure that:

  • every line is short enough and can be easily read
  • the meaning is clear
  • the subtitles sound natural in your language

Because of this a review can take almost just as long as the translation - you have to think about every line and multiple ways to improve it. The quality of the translation lies in your hands just as much as in the hands of the translator.

Always keep in mind the audience, the people who will spend their time watching the video which you translated - you want to give them a good experience!

Reviewers should also contact the translator and discuss any changes made. Both of your names will appear next to the translated talk, so make sure that you can be proud of it :)

Recommended workflow

  1. Watch the talk to understand it thoroughly and check the quality. If the quality is so poor that you have to change most of the lines then don't make changes but send it back to the translator with explanations and comments on how to improve it. If it is fine, start reviewing.
  2. Do a sweep for common mistakes in meaning, spelling, obvious lines that are too long and things that sound unnatural in your language.
  3. Watch the talk and pause every time something looks strange or you don't manage to read the subtitles in the time given. Fix and shorten. See this article for tips on compressing subtitles.
  4. Send the translator the link to your final draft so they can see what changes you made. You should both agree on the best final version and be ready to learn from each other!
  5. Watch the talk without sound, only with subtitles on - if it's good, you can accept it :)

Most common types of mistakes in translations

1. Spelling (Install a spell checker for your browser, or if you have one, install a spelling dictionary for your language

2. Line length - When you are done with your review, watch the talk without the sound. This will force you to focus on reading and seeing how fast you can read. If you fail to read a line twice then you should shorten it (another tip: make sure you can read the line and still have time to look at the video). This is very important because other people do not know the text like you do, and do not read as fast as you do, so they will need more time :)

Ways to shorten the lines:

a) Remove fluff which does not add to the meaning, for example: Err, Well, very, Anyway,...

b) Remove repetitions. If something is obvious from the context then there is no need to say it.

c) Break the lines differently: move part of a meaning to the next or previous line which is shorter

d) Compress two lines into one and double it. In TED player similar lines show without blinking.

e) Find shorter synonyms or find a more common, thus easier to process, synonym.

More tips here.

3. Literal translation Most importantly: Would a native speaker say it like you just wrote it, or would they use a different phrase to explain the same meaning? Does it sound natural?

4. Punctuation Make sure to learn your language-specific punctuation rules. Make sure you don't follow the English punctuation by accident.

5. Line breaks Learn how to break lines here. Rule of thumb: If a line could be used as an answer to a question on its own, then it is good, if there is an element which does not fit then it should be moved.

6. Language specific errors Navigate to your language in the sidebar of this page and see if there is a list of common errors available.

7. Meaning Think: What does the person speaking mean? Is the message clear? Do I understand? Could I explain it myself?

8. Specialized vocabulary Do your research. Proper names are very rarely translated in a straightforward way. The easiest way to do it is to check the term in English Wikipedia and then navigate to your language. You can also try the KudoZ term archive, and ask a new question if you can't find anything in the available answers. Also remember that proper names (of people or places) may not be spelled the same way in your language as they are in English (for example, Istanbul in English, but Estambul in Spanish). To learn more about searching for terms, watch this video

9. Units of measurement Check if the translator converted them to the ones most commonly used in your language, for example. miles to kilometers.